Deepfakes Are Deeply Worrying
Bill Hader’s face morphs to Tom Cruise’s in a YouTube clip. (Screenshot via YouTube/Ctrl Shift Face)
Cyber hackers are remembered as the villains of 2016. Trump, Putin, and Florida rednecks are, too, of course: but they, at least, have faces. Faceless villains — the types that appear as silhouettes in comic books, or as dementors in Harry Potter, or as good ole Grim Reaper — are far more terrifying.
Intelligence officials, including the director of the FBI, have said that they expect an increase in foreign meddling in 2020. Naturally, then, so does the Democratic National Committee (DNC). In order to emphasize the seriousness of this threat, earlier this month, at a “hackers” convention in Las Vegas, the DNC showed a video of their chairman Tom Perez apologizing for not being able to attend . . . but, of course, Perez said no such thing! He only appeared to have said this because of the work of artificial-intelligence experts, who, using a kind of photoshop for videos, made what’s known as a “deepfake.”
When done well, deepfakes are uncanny. Recently, for instance, a YouTuber used material from a 2008 interview with David Letterman to show the comedian Bill Hader seamlessly morph into Tom Cruise, then Seth Rogan. This benign celebrity deepfake went viral — deservedly, since it was well done. But what if this technology were to be used for malicious purposes? Like pornography or propaganda?
These are not academic concerns. “Deepfake” was coined on Reddit, a U.S. discussion website, by an account with the same name. The owner of this account was producing sex videos of women celebrities — fake, of course — by plastering their faces onto the bodies of porn stars. The harm of this can hardly be overstated. Even if a person knows they are watching a deepfake, some things simply cannot be unseen. Though this account (and similar ones) were removed from the site: the technological cat — growling, purring, and ravenously hungry for more — was out the bag.
The trouble is that the software used to create deepfakes is fairly easy to obtain and access. The more basic versions have already been downloaded hundreds of thousands of times. So how much technology can our politics endure? Deepfakes are deeply worrying.
(function() {
if("function" === typeof jwplayer) {
var jwp = jwplayer(document.querySelectorAll(".jw-player-container div.jwplayer")[0]) || null;
if(jwp) {
var episode = jwp.getConfig().playlist[0];
var pubdate = new Date(episode.pubdate * 1000);
var prelimMonth = pubdate.getUTCMonth() + 1;
var month = prelimMonth.length > 1 ? prelimMonth : "0" + prelimMonth;
var prelimDate = pubdate.getUTCDate();
var date = prelimDate.length > 1 ? prelimDate : "0" + prelimDate;
var finalDate = pubdate.getUTCFullYear() + "-" + month + "-" + date;
var title = episode.title;
var labelMapping = "c3="nationalreview", c4="*null", c6="*null", ns_st_st="National Review", ns_st_pu="National Review", ns_st_pr="" + title + "", ns_st_ep="" + title + "", ns_st_sn="*null", ns_st_en="*null", ns_st_ge="News", ns_st_ia="0", ns_st_ce="0", ns_st_ddt="" + finalDate + "", ns_st_tdt="*null"";
jwp.on("ready", function () {
ns_.StreamingAnalytics.JWPlayer(jwp, {
publisherId: "23390304",
labelmapping: labelMapping,
});
});
}
}
})();